| 1806 | Rev. Elias Mitchell of Chester |
| Rev. Coble Greer | |
| Rev. Elisha Eubanks | |
| 1830-1868 | Rev. Wright |
| Rev. Dabner Duncan | |
| Rev. Richard Woodruff | |
| Rev. Phillips | |
| Rev. Kendricks | |
| 1868-1880 | Rev. J.C. Jeter |
| Rev. Carte R. Jeter | |
| Rev. J.T. Gwinn | |
| Rev. J.C. Humphries | |
| 1880-1885 | Rev. C.T. Scaife |
| 1883 | Rev. A.J. Greis |
| 1886-1889 | Rev. H.K. Ezell |
| Rev. L.M. Rice | |
| Rev. C.R. Williford | |
| Rev. B.C. Lamfley | |
| Rev. J.N. Booth | |
| Rev. C.C. Vaughan | |
| Rev. T.H. Garrett | |
| ` | Rev. L.M. Rice |
| 1900-1906 | Rev. J.C. Lawson |
| Rev. C.H. Holland | |
| 1906-1936 | Rev. L.M. Rice |
| Rev. S.W. Jolly | |
| Rev. Richardson | |
| Rev. Stoudmire | |
| Rev. Trogdon | |
| Rev. K.D. Smith | |
| Rev. States W. Jolly | |
| Rev. J.R. Moore | |
| Rev. R.P. Lamb | |
| Rev. Stone | |
| Rev. C.F. Prince | |
| Rev. F.L. Snyder | |
| Rev. E. A. McDowell, Jr. | |
| 1936-1940 | Rev. Carl Campbell |
| 1941-1943 | Rev. Carl Giers |
| 1943-1944 | Rev. Claude Campbell |
| Rev. Luther Knight | |
| 1946-1952 | Rev. J.D. Gulledge |
| 1953 | Rev. Conrad Cato |
| 1953-1956 | Rev. Coy R. Bates |
| 1957-1962 | Rev. Maurice Garner* |
| 1962 | Rev. States W. Jolly |
| 1962-1969 | Rev. Weldon Morgan |
| 1969-1980 | Rev. Kelly Weeks |
| 1980-1982 | Rev. Marion Hendrix** |
| 1982-1990 | Rev. Joel Burke |
| 1990-1991 | Rev. Carl Fiske** |
| 1991-1996 | Rev. John Abel |
| 1996 | Rev. Carl Fiske** |
| 1996-1998 | Dr. Joe Bridges** |
| 1998-2001 | Rev. Jerry Ford |
| 2001-2004 | Rev. David Toney |
| 2004 | Rev. Guy Langston** |
| 2004-2010 | Rev. Larry Padgett |
| 2010-2019 | Rev. Brian Childers |
| 2019-2025 | Rev. Lynn Ford (** 2019-21) |
| 2025 | Rev. Alex Calhoun |
* First full-time pastor | ** Interim
